Provisions for Fairness: Dependant Support Claims in Ontario

Retro effect faded and toned image of a businessman holding white card with Thank you for your support sign on it.

Estate disputes in Ontario often extend beyond contesting the validity of a will. A significant aspect of estate litigation involves dependant support claims, a legal avenue available to certain individuals who believe they have not been adequately provided for in the deceased’s estate.

Dependant support claims are rooted in the notion that individuals who were financially dependent on the deceased at the time of their death should be entitled to support from the estate. These claims aim to address situations where the deceased, intentionally or unintentionally, did not make adequate provisions for their dependants in the will.

In Ontario, the Succession Law Reform Act (SLRA) governs dependant support claims, providing a statutory framework that outlines the rights of dependants and the court’s authority to make orders for support.

Eligibility for Dependant Support Claims

The SLRA outlines specific categories of individuals who may bring a dependant support claim. These include:

Spouses:

  1. Married spouses or individuals who lived with the deceased in a conjugal relationship continuously for at least three years.

Children:

  1. Biological and adopted children of the deceased.

Parents and Siblings:

  1. Individuals who can establish that they had a relationship of some permanence with the deceased, such as a sibling or parent of the deceased, and to whom the deceased was providing ongoing support to at the time of their death.

Assessing the Need for Support

The court, when determining a dependant support claim, considers various factors to assess the dependant’s needs and the deceased’s means and assets. Key considerations include:

Financial Resources and Obligations:

  1. The court evaluates the financial circumstances of both the dependant and the estate, considering assets, liabilities, and ongoing financial obligations.

Dependant’s Current and Future Needs:

  1. The court assesses the dependant’s current and future financial needs, taking into account factors such as age, health, and standard of living.

Contributions to the Estate:

  1. Contributions made by the dependant to the deceased’s estate, both financial and non-financial, are considered.

Any Agreements Between the Parties:

  1. If there were any agreements or arrangements between the deceased and the dependant, the court will examine these to determine their impact on the claim.

Time Limit for Dependant Support Claims

It’s essential to note that dependant support claims must be filed within six months from the issuance of the Certificate of Appointment of Estate Trustee (commonly known as probate). Failing to meet this deadline may result in losing the right to pursue a dependant support claim. However, the court may extend the time limit in exceptional circumstances.

Variation of Support Orders

In some cases, a court may grant an order for dependant support, but circumstances can change over time. The SLRA allows for the variation of support orders, providing flexibility to address changing needs or financial circumstances of the dependant or the estate.

Challenging a Will and Dependant Support Claims

It’s crucial to understand that dependant support claims and will challenges are distinct legal actions. Challenging the validity of a will involves questioning its formation, such as issues of capacity, undue influence, or improper execution. On the other hand, dependant support claims focus on addressing the financial needs of eligible dependants, irrespective of the will’s validity.

Recent Trends and Evolving Considerations

In recent years, there has been a shift in societal structures, leading to changes in family dynamics. This has prompted a reevaluation of how the law addresses dependant support claims. Courts are increasingly attuned to diverse family arrangements, recognizing the varied forms of relationships that may give rise to dependant support claims.

Additionally, the aging population has brought attention to the financial challenges faced by older dependants, such as elderly parents who may have been financially dependent on their deceased adult child. The evolving landscape reflects a growing awareness of the need for flexibility in assessing and accommodating the financial needs of dependants.

Conclusion

Dependant support claims form a vital component of Ontario’s estate law, aiming to ensure fair and equitable provisions for individuals who were financially dependent on the deceased. Understanding the eligibility criteria, factors considered by the court, and the evolving dynamics in this area is essential for both dependants and estate trustees.

As Ontario’s legal landscape continues to adapt to societal changes, staying informed about recent court decisions and legislative developments related to dependant support claims is crucial. Navigating the complexities of dependant support claims requires a nuanced understanding of estate law in Ontario. Engaging the services of an experienced estate litigation lawyer is crucial for both dependants seeking support and estate trustees defending against such claims.

Recent Post

Recent Amendments to the Succession Law Reform Act : What you need to know.

Provisions for Fairness: Dependant Support Claims in Ontario

Challenging a Will: Navigating the Complex Web of Contesting a Will in Ontario

Substantial Compliance Comes to Ontario

Pre-Death Will Challenges – is it possible?